The Circleville Letters: The Poison Pen Mystery

The Circleville Letters case unleashed a reign of anonymous threats, stalking, and psychological terror across a small Ohio town. 

For years, residents lived in fear of a writer who seemed to know their darkest secrets.

This Tales of the Twisted true crime podcast episode blends creepy real stories, dark history, and unsolved mysteries to unravel a decades-long investigation filled with conspiracies, forged evidence, and unsettling questions.

The letters targeted school officials, townspeople, and even law enforcement. When a suspicious death and a booby-trapped sign entered the mix, the case took an even darker turn. One man was convicted—but the letters continued.Did the wrong person go to prison? 

And who was really controlling Circleville from the shadows?